Mistaken Identity? Ch. 03

We stood there for what seemed like a long moment of silence. Kathleen dripping wet and naked with the towel on the floor in front of her. Sherry staring at her pussy. I knew Sherry had played the field before her marriage. She was loose, sleeping with various men and women. I only ever saw her flirt with a few women in the past, but seeing her stare at Kathleen's pussy, like that, was a definite turn-on for me.

Just at that moment, the doorbell rang. We all looked at one another in surprise.

"I'll get it. Whatever you do, don't get dressed." Sherry said while looking at Kathleen's slick nudity.

Kathleen walked over to me seductively, as Sherry exited the room, and ran down the stairs to answer the front door. Kathleen kissed me, and rubbed her naked body up against me. Before I knew what hit me, I had a rock-hard erection that needed attention. Kathleen rubbed her pussy up against it teasingly. We continued kissing as I wondered who it could be at the front door.

I heard Sherry talking to someone. It sounded like another woman, but I could faintly hear their voices as Kathleen traced my earlobe with her tongue. I heard Sherry and the other woman walk into another room as they continued to talk. I dismissed any thought of who it might be as Kathleen cupped my cock in her hands and rubbed it against her soft pussy.

We were about to consummate our sexual act when I heard footsteps on the stairs outside my room and Sherry quickly entered the room without knocking. She paused to watch us for a moment.

"You'll never guess who was at the door." She said in an excited voice.

"Who?" I asked.

"Your ex. The slut. Beth." Sherry said.

"What did she want?" I asked a little annoyed that Beth would come back after her actions.

My annoyance grew at her audacity. She always expected forgiveness no matter her actions or who it hurt.

"Well she wanted to talk to you. But first she wanted to apologize to me for sleeping with my soon-to-be-ex-husband." Sherry said as she folded her arms over her ample breasts.

"Is she gone?" I asked, knowing the answer.

Sherry shook her head "No." as I expected she would.

"Hmmmm, I have an idea. She wants to hang around, maybe we can punish her." I said thinking up my scheme.

"How?" Kathleen interjected.

I took a bottle off the nightstand next to my waterbed. I held it up.

"Two of these will do the trick. They will knock her out. Believe me I've seen her take them for a headache. She can barely handle one. Two will do the trick for sure. But first, I want to play a cruel trick on her for what she did. Here's the plan.........." I said as I continued on.

Sherry ran back downstairs with two of the pills that will dissolve in Beth's drink. Kathleen smiled at me and sat on the bed. I jumped on her, and kissed her, before quietly exiting the room.

I went into the other room where Sherry's husband was staying the night before, until we kicked him out this morning. I shut the blinds